Discussion about this post

User's avatar
gadfly's avatar

This is interesting. Do you have more work anywhere online that I could read? (Forgive me if I'm addressing a famous author, I plead ignorance about a lot going on these days.)

Expand full comment
Paul L's avatar

Here is my ‘critique’ for your edification.

As I mentioned before, I waited until after you posted the Voice-Over, and I’m glad I did. First, I’m a speed-reader, and it really wouldn’t have done it justice to speed-read this piece. I would have skimmed over a lot of good little details. Second, I enjoyed hearing it in your voice, as it is always hard to read a piece that has a lot of internal monologue.

Example,

“Well this should be interesting!”

and

“And me, leaving the house without my derby!

I don’t automatically read that as something the narrator says. But I heard it properly in the audio version.

As for syntax & grammar, I won’t get into that much, except to mention one tip. Always watch for repeated words and eliminate, if you can. Example,

"and just alive enough to be interesting enough"

It looks weird to see the same word repeated. Instead, try,

"and just alive enough to be sufficiently interesting"

But I’m sure you really want to know how the whole piece landed. It was a piece that started out as a personal anecdote about a book shop, but developed into a story about the narrator and about our modern world, and ended with poem, and that is a difficult thing to stitch together, but I think it worked. It revealed a lot about you that I wouldn’t see in your other posts. Some of these lines are real gold, like this one

“You didn’t buy books there, you bought a snapshot of the legacy of the culture and knowledge of man.”

It also struck me in several ways, personally. Example,

“Have sight of Proteus rising from the sea;”

that made me chuckle because Proteus is the name of the main character in my first book, Into the Fifth World!

But the piece really overlapped with what I’m researching right now, and this research will probably end up becoming a full book. In this line —

“Would it be better to be a pagan raised on old mythology than be a part of our spiritually disconnected modern world?”

I would answer Yes. Yes, it was better in the ancient pagan societies because they were virtuous out of necessity. It was for survival of the society, not simply because someone made up an arbitrary rule. And today, because survival is presumed, some tend to think that virtues are, as I said, simply arbitrary rules rather than necessities for survival.

And I place the blame at the Reformation, although it took a few centuries for the full decline to unravel … the Enlightenment, then Evolution, then Marxism, then Progressivism, finally contraception & divorce. A lot of people blame modern technology only, but the loss of virtue happened before then.

Anyway, that’s my thesis I’m working on, and your piece overlapped into a lot of similar themes.

“We have given our hearts away!”

For this, for everything, we are out of tune;

And your poem at the end, it really captured a sense of optimism of a return to the kind of appreciation of the good, true and beautiful that will return once we recognize and undo the errors rooted in the Reformation. That’s my task ahead for later this year.

Now, if you’ll excuse me, I have a sudden urge to go out and buy a derby!

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts